SPECIAL REPORT No 1/98 in respect of bilateral financial and technical cooperation with non-Member Mediterranean Countries together with the Commission's replies (submitted pursuant to Article 188C, paragraph 4, indent 2, of the EC Treaty) (98/C 98/01)
CONTENTS
Paragraph PagereferenceGENERAL INTRODUCTION . 1 - 7 2
Background to the audit . 1 - 4 2
Approach adopted and scope of the audit . 5 - 7 3
THE PROTOCOL SYSTEM . 8 - 28 4
General Presentation . 8 - 15 4
The special features of the Third and Fourth Protocols . 12 - 15 6
Implementation of the Protocols . 16 - 24 6
Progression from one Protocol to the next . 16 - 18 6
Utilisation of appropriations as at 31 December 1996 . 19 - 20 8
Budgetary presentation . 21 10
Legality under Community law . 22 - 24 10
Conclusions concerning the system of Protocols . 25 - 28 10
OPERATIONS MANAGED DIRECTLY BY THE COMMISSION . 29 - 103 11
Management and monitoring instruments . 30 - 42 11
The financing agreements . 30 - 33 11
Information technology . 34 - 36 12
The organisation and resources of the departments involved . 37 - 42 12
The consequences for the implementation of the projects . 43 - 84 13
Schedule for the completion of the projects . 44 - 49 13
Financial management and monitoring of the projects . 50 - 68 14
Evaluation and external audits . 69 - 71 16
Amendments to the initial decisions . 72 - 80 17
Services provided by the technical assistance units . 81 - 84 18
Management by those responsible for the projects and results obtained . 85 - 98 18
Observations in respect of the accounts and finances . 85 - 87 18
The results recorded and the survival of the projects . 88 - 98 18
Conclusions in respect of the management of the projects . 99 - 103 19
THE MANAGEMENT OF OPERATIONS ADMINISTERED BY THE EIB ON BEHALF OF THE COMMISSION AND THE AUDIT OF THESE OPERATIONS . 104 - 149 20
General presentation of the audit . 104 - 107 20
The system of risk capital management . 108 - 136 22
The purpose of risk capital and conditions of eligibility . 108 - 110 22
Description of the management system . 111 - 121 22
The Court's observations at the conclusion of the audit . 122 - 136 23
The management of interest-rate subsidies . 137 - 149 26
Introduction . 137 - 138 26
Audit findings . 139 - 146 26
Observations relating to the management of interest-rate subsidies . 147 - 149 29
GENERAL CONCLUSIONS . 150 - 160 29
Considerations relating to the system of Protocols . 150 - 152 29