Two of the four projects audited in Jordan did not have separate accounts while for two others the only accounts kept were those of the technical assistance unit. It should be added that in the case of the National Soil Map and Land Use project (SEM/03/628/005), the accounts, which were kept by the TA, did not present the appropriations under the budgetary headings stipulated in the FA, thus making it impossible to monitor their utilisation.
In the case of the Nile Valley Regional Project in Egypt (SEM/03/220/008A), the only accounts were kept by the technical assistance. Neither the national coordinators for the various research programmes nor the local research centres kept accounts.
In spite of the generally high quality of the management of the «Rjim Maatoug» project (SEM/03/212/010), the checks carried out showed that the managers of the project did not award a local contract for the purchase of tractors to the lowest bidder and the files do not supply a satisfactory explanation for this decision, which contravenes the public tendering regulations.
The results recorded and the survival of the projects
The projects' success depends on the partners fulfilling their commitments and on an adequate system of management, the definition of which is a result, or should be a result, of feasibility studies. Bearing in mind these two criteria, the controls conducted by the Court revealed contrasting situations. The shortfall in the results achieved compared to the objectives set out in the FAs, and doubts about the ability of the following projects to survive, should be emphasised.
The Helwan Waste Water project (SEM/03/220/005A), which has received, commencing with the first protocol, almost 87 Mio ECU, can still not be taken over by the local institutions. Two administrations share responsibility for the project. Responsibility for the execution of the work lies with the Cairo Waste Water Organisation (CWO) which, after its final inspection of the work done, hands it over to the General Organisation For Sanitary Drainage (GOSD), which is responsible for the management of installations and the distribution of water. Checks carried out on the spot have shown that neither of these two institutions is in a position to perform its tasks in an accceptable fashion and that the project as a whole only works thanks to the technical assistance.