The Court's audit includes an analysis of the system of Protocols and the Commission's management of them. In respect of the latter, it looks more specifically at the systems set up from the planning of the aid up to the ex-post evaluation of the projects, including the procedures for selecting technical assistance and the examination of the services technical assistance provides.
The audit involved visits to four countries: Egypt, Jordan, Morocco and Tunisia. In this connection, detailed audits were carried out on a sample of 16 projects, which are shown in summary form in Table No 1.
TABLE 1 SAMPLE - SUMMARY PROJECTS
>TABLE>
>TABLE>
>TABLE>
>TABLE>
This Report consists of three parts. The first introduces the system of Protocols and includes the observations arising from the Court's examination of the model of cooperation created through the system of Protocols. The second is devoted to the operations that were managed directly by the Commission. The third, finally, deals with those operations which were managed under mandate by the EIB.
THE PROTOCOL SYSTEM
General Presentation
The Protocols, which are bilateral agreements under Article 238 of the EC Treaty, were initiated in 1979. They form an overall legal framework for financial and technical cooperation between the European Community and each NMC for a given period (normally five years). Thus, this approach to cooperation is characterised by two levels of organisation, because the funding of any given project requires the signing of a specific financing agreement.
The Protocols adopt an overall budget, specify the source of the appropriations, depending on whether they come from the general budget of the Community or EIB own resources, and the nature of the financing - non-refundable aid, risk capital or loans.
The total aid budget made available to the seven countries in question amounted to 3 548 Mio ECU. Of this amount, 2 158 Mio ECU (60,8 %) was financed from EIB own resources and 1 390 Mio ECU (39,2 %) from the general budget (1 273 Mio ECU in grants and 117 Mio ECU in the form of risk capital). Tables No 2a and 2b give a breakdown of this distribution for each of the countries concerned. Together with those for the first two series of Protocols, these sums amount to 5 232 Mio ECU, 2 112 Mio ECU of which comes from the Community budget and 3 120 Mio ECU from the EIB's own resources.
OVERALL BUDGET FOR THE THIRD AND FOURTH PROTOCOLS
>TABLE>
>TABLE>