One NMC's responsible authorities underlined, moreover, that the basic value of this financial instrument was to allow the implementation of quality projects which, however, were difficult to finance by conventional bank loans because of the impossibility on the part of their sponsors of offering sufficient guarantees. The purpose of the risk capital, therefore, is to encourage the creation of a new generation of entrepreneurs, which was not really the case for the projects financed in Egypt and was only partly the case for those financed in Morocco and Tunisia.
Overall monitoring of the operations by the EIB
As far as the monitoring of documents is concerned, it was observed that, in general, the IFIs did not fulfil their contractual obligations in respect of forwarding to the EIB, on a regular basis, information sheets on the state of their risk capital portfolio or on the financial situation of each beneficiary.
In May 1993 the EIB employed a consultant, at its own expense, to evaluate operations financed in Morocco on the basis of a large sample covering 37 projects. Several of the projects examined as part of the Court's audit had also been evaluated by this consultant or had been audited by the EIB. The Court found similarities in the findings of these audits.
The results achieved
The management of risk capital within the framework of the implementation of the Third Protocols is characterised by:
an even distribution of the loans to the beneficiaries in the various sectors of activity in the NMCs, particularly in Morocco and Tunisia, where seven and nine sectors of activity respectively have benefited from this financial instrument;
a leverage effect on investments, whereby the priority given to the creation of joint enterprises has encouraged an inflow of foreign capital;
the creation of 5 200 jobs, directly, in Morocco and more that 1 900 in Tunisia and Egypt. In addition, in these latter two countries, two other audited operations were able to save respectively 400 and 500 jobs which were under threat;
a selection of projects designed to improve the balance of foreign trade.
The implementation of the Fourth Protocols