Audits carried out in Egypt confirmed this analysis. In two of the three projects concerned, the amount committed was, for one of them, over 700 000 ECU, or 25 % too high, and for the other it was over 250 000 ECU, or 13 % too high. In the first case the unused and unneeded funds remained blocked from March 1994 onwards, in the second, from December 1992 onwards. In both cases the funds in question were still in the account as 'restant à liquider` (still outstanding) at the end of 1995, and were carried over until 1996 and decommitted in July only in the first case.
In the third case, the initial EIB own resources loan was fixed at 35 Mio ECU, with an estimated interest rate subsidy of 5,6 Mio ECU. At the end of 1993, the bank decided to reduce the size of its loan to 28 Mio ECU, as the promoter had reduced the scale of the project, but did not inform the Commission of this until June 1994. The Commission, however, failed to take action at this point to reduce the funds committed for the interest rate subsidy. A balance of over 3 Mio ECU remained committed throughout 1994 and 1995, with a final payment being made in December 1995. It was not until July 1996 that the remaining funds were decommitted. Again, this project provides evidence of a lack of sufficiently close management of budgetary funds by the Commission's services. The bank should also have informed the Commission more promptly of its decision to reduce the size of its loan.
Observations relating to the management of interest-rate subsidies
The findings described above demonstrate the poor quality of the controls of the justification for the amounts requested by the EIB for interest-rate subsidies. The Commission did not ask for any explanation of the initial amount, of the reasons for the existence of an unexpended balance at the end of an operation, or, on the other hand, of the reasons which led the EIB to request an increase in the appropriations initially committed. The weakness of the Commission's monitoring is confirmed by the number of unexpended balances to be decommitted and the length of time they have been in existence.
Council Regulation (EEC) No 1762/92 restored to the Commission control over financing decisions relating to interest-rate subsidies. It is for the Commission to use it to ensure that the application file submitted by the EIB allows the Commission to check whether the appropriations requested are justified in principle and in terms of the amount.