, Special Report No 1/98 in respect of bilateral financial and technical cooperation with…

In forcesince 29 Jan 1998
97.

The project involving loan operations in favour of small and medium-sized enterprises in Tunisia (SEM/03/212/015) has had an unwanted effect. The farmers' level of indebtedness increased considerably when rates were raised (see paragraph 73). The controls carried out revealed that more than 80 % of the farmers were not able to support the burden of their debts. As national legislation forbids access to new financing if there are delays in repayments, the result is that even the continued existence of some agricultural holdings has been jeopardised.

98.

Two of the four projects in the sample which were financed in Jordan only partially achieved the desired objectives and their survival also appears fraught with difficulties. On the other hand, the National Soil Map and Land Use project (SEM/03/628/005) may be considered a success as it has allowed a real transfer of know-how to the benefit of the local departments. Two aspects in particular account for this success: the project was well defined from the beginning by Jordanian technicians and the technical assistance worked in close cooperation with them.

Conclusions in respect of the management of the projects

99.

An examination of the management of the projects shows that the main weaknesses pointed out in the Court's Special Report No 3/91 still persist in spite of the commitments to remedy them given by the Commission.

100.

The inadequacy of the human resources, the lack of clarity in the division of responsibilities between the various departments and of competences between the Commission's headquarters in Brussels and its Delegations in the field - all these aspects have contributed to the Commission's failure, on the whole, to cope with the management of the projects.

101.

The limitations of the management tools aggravate this situation:

(a)

the computer software that the Commission has at its disposal does not enable it to keep real auxiliary accounts for projects which are directly linked to the implementation of the budget, or even accounts giving a comprehensive view of the financial situation of these projects;

(b)

the wording of the financing agreements is not precise enough when specifying the nature of contractual obligations, the management framework and the instruments for monitoring operations;

(c)

the audit contracts do not define clearly the information that the Commission expects from external controls.