, Special Report No 1/98 in respect of bilateral financial and technical cooperation with…

In forcesince 29 Jan 1998
106.

The management of interest subsidies was mainly audited on the basis of an examination of the Commission's files. For the management of risk capital, the controls were complemented by an analysis of a sample of projects, most of which were the subject of inspections on the spot (see Table 7). These checks covered:

(a)

whether the use of these resources was consistent with the objectives assigned to them in the protocols;

(b)

the quality of the management by the mandated body by means of an examination of the structures employed and the results obtained;

(c)

the monitoring of these various operations by the Commission.

>TABLE>

107.

Taking into account the number of financial instruments, on the one hand, which the Commission has entrusted to EIB management and, on the other, the constraints experienced in connection with the organisation of the external audit of the EIB, the obligation to organise, systematically, a joint audit with the EIB, represents a real constraint on the Court. For this reason, it was materially impossible to carry out controls, on the spot, on a large number of projects which had benefited from budget finance in the form of interest-rate subsidies.

The system of risk capital management

The purpose of risk capital and conditions of eligibility

108.

Risk capital is, according to the terms of the Protocols, intended primarily to help in making equity capital or the like available to private and public undertakings, in particular those in which natural or legal persons from Member States of the Community have participations. They are available to all sectors of the economies of the NMCs.

109.

The extremely broad formulation of the Protocols led the EIB to define three conditions for the eligibility of projects for risk capital. Two of these conditions concern the actual qualities of the projects, i.e. their economic value and their financial viability. The third concerns the decisive role which risk capital must play in the execution of the project.

110.

The EIB, however, interprets this final condition very generously. It is considered to be fulfilled when the absence of this financing would lead to delays in the operation, to an upset in the balance of the relationship between the local and European partners or would influence other hesitant donors unfavourably.

Description of the management system