, Special Report No 1/98 in respect of bilateral financial and technical cooperation with…

In forcesince 29 Jan 1998
118.

Nevertheless, the IFI does not have autonomous powers of decision in respect of the allocation of risk capital. It must send the file relating to the project and the result of its appraisal to the EIB to obtain its approval. This file contains, at the least, according to the terms of the contract, a standardised information sheet.

119.

After examination of the forwarded file, the EIB takes an allocation decision by which the IFI is authorised to conclude the financing contract with the final beneficiary.

120.

The monitoring of the operations is conducted according to two complementary procedures. Contracts signed with the IFI provide for monitoring of documentation, whereby information on the state of their risk capital portfolio and on the financial situation of each beneficiary is sent to the EIB on a regular basis. This information is collated in standardised sheets, a specimen of which is attached to the contract. This monitoring is complemented by inspections on the spot which the EIB carries out directly or by despatching consultants recruited specifically for this purpose.

121.

In the case of the global lines of credit granted to the State of Morocco, its Treasury ensures, prior to the release of the funds, that the contractual conditions have been fulfilled by the beneficiary. In parallel with this, it monitors the projects by examining the financial balance sheets which are sent to it.

The Court's observations at the conclusion of the audit

The appraisal of the projects

122.

The most commonly encountered weakness concerned the information collated on the European companies associated with the joint enterprise, whose exact situation and the extent of whose commitment cannot be assessed on the basis of the material contained in the appraisal files forwarded to the Court. The controls carried out demonstrated the close connection between the quality of the partners involved and the success or, on the contrary, failure of the projects financed.

123.

The second weakness demonstrated by an analysis of the projects in the sample and by an examination of the available documents, concerns the relative frequency of under-estimation of the investment budgets and, in particular, of the working capital requirements.