The implementation of the Third and Fourth Protocols in favour of the seven countries concerned by this audit resulted in total commitments, as at 31 December 1996, of 114,7 Mio ECU in commitment appropriations, of which 58,2 Mio ECU had been paid. In addition, 5,3 Mio ECU in committed appropriations, had lapsed. At the close of the accounts for the financial year 1996, the balance of appropriations committed and not paid in interest-rate subsidies for the overall budgets of the Third and Fourth Protocols came to 51,1 Mio ECU, i. e. 44,5 % of the total committed (Table 9).
>TABLE>
Dormant commitments and monitoring
An examination of the Commission's files revealed the existence of a large volume of commitment appropriations which were either tied up prematurely or represented an amount in excess of the requirements of the operations concerned.
This phenomenon demonstrates the weakness of the Commission's monitoring: it did not carry out the necessary controls to check whether the amount committed was justified and did not set up a procedure for the closure of completed projects at the end of each year.
Premature tying-up of commitment appropriations
Overall, the Court's examination of the Commission's accounts showed that appropriations committed and amounting to 27,5 Mio ECU remained unused over periods exceeding two years. These amounts, as Table 10b shows, derived from seven projects, in respect of four of which, at the time of the audit, no payments had been made.
INTEREST-RATE SUBSIDIES - DORMANT COMMITMENTS
>TABLE>
>TABLE>
Unexpended balances to be decommitted
The Court's review of the operations financed with interest-rate subsidies within the framework of the Third and Fourth Protocols, and also of the Second, showed that appropriations corresponding to projects for which the EIB had made the final payment and informed the Commission were still open in the Commission's accounts with unexpended balances of very long standing. In one case, the last payment was made in 1990.
Table 10a shows that eleven projects, accounting for almost 1,25 Mio ECU, fall within this category, one unexpended balance of 168 320 ECU even deriving from two commitments made under the Second Protocols with Jordan. The setting-up of a systematic procedure for the annual closure of operations would enable such a situation, where appropriations are frozen to no useful purpose and merely congest the accounts, to be avoided.