, Special Report No 1/98 in respect of bilateral financial and technical cooperation with…

In forcesince 29 Jan 1998
21.

Budgetary appropriations made available under heading B7-4051 not only include the amounts agreed in the Third and Fourth Protocols but also the additional appropriations for the structural adjustment support programmes to which the Fourth Protocols refer. In the interest of greater clarity in the budget and its implementation, it would have been preferable to apply the principle of specification to these appropriations more rigorously, and to enter the Protocol budgets and those additional amounts involved in the structural adjustment support measures under separate headings.

Legality under Community law

22.

In its Special Report No 3/91 the Court points out that Council Regulation No 3973/86 (8) only refers explicitly, in its recitals, to the Second Protocols. In its replies the Commission acknowledged the pertinence of this observation. The Court notes that Regulation (EEC) No 1762/92 on the application of the Protocols concluded between the Community and the NMCs concerning financial and technical cooperation was not adopted by the Council until 29 June 1992. As the Council had not taken a decision to extend the validity of Regulation No 3973/86, the third series of Protocols was implemented in the absence of any legal base.

23.

This situation had consequences for the decision-making arrangements concerning interest-rate subsidies under the Third Protocols. In its Opinion No 2/86 (9), the Court argued that the procedure contained in the proposed regulation of 1986 was unsatisfactory, and that it was necessary 'to safeguard the prerogatives of the authority responsible for implementing the budget` by giving the Commission the power to decide in favour of, or against, granting an interest-rate subsidy on a loan awarded by the EIB. This observation was not taken into account when Council Regulation (EC) No 3973/86 was adopted. It was, however, taken into account in Council Regulation (EC) No 1762/92. Had steps been taken to ensure that there was a proper legal base for implementation of the Third Protocols, the power of the Commission to decide on interest rate subsidies could have been correctly set out in a regulation from 1988. As it was, the unsatisfactory decision rules continued for a further four years.

  • celex=31986R3973
  • celex=31992R1762