, Special Report No 3/98 concerning the implementation by the Commission of EU policy and…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1998
121.

However, a final report was submitted to the Commission in October 1996, 25 months after the deadline set for the first phase (September 1994) and ten months after that set for the second phase (December 1995). The total cost of the assessment was 211 887 ECU and, according to the Commission, the report already contained most of the information for the overall assessment of the Envireg CI.

122.

In the Court's opinion, however, the report did not achieve the assessment objectives set out and laid down in the contract and, in particular:

(a)

the analysis of administrative procedures and management systems was purely descriptive, with wide variations in quality between Member States;

(b)

the report did not compare programming and implementation methods and did not evaluate the management structures in relation to the objectives pursued;

(c)

there was no analysis of the physical results of the cofinanced programmes and projects and no evaluations which might have made it possible to measure the impact of these contributions on the basis of suitable indicators (with the exception of Portugal);

(d)

the expected budgetary and financial analyses were not carried out;

(e)

there was insufficient discussion of the Envireg CI's impact in terms of resolving the environmental problems which the initiative was to address (water pollution, orderly development of coastal areas, etc);

(f)

the report did not make any connection between Envireg and economic development and/or the development of tourism in the region concerned.

The data contained in the report cannot be used as the basis for conclusions about the impact of the Envireg CI. Lastly, the scientific assessment committee has not even been set up.