, Special Report No 3/98 concerning the implementation by the Commission of EU policy and…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1998
60.

There was a similar type of problem with other projects financed by ERDF under the old 1989-93 CSF. The projects in question started in 1990 and were finalised after the date on which the Directive entered into force, but did not necessarily comply with it.

61.

This applied to the following projects in particular:

(a)

the Arteixo integrated drainage project (Spain), which provided only pre-treatment, whereas the secondary type is required;

(b)

the collector and underwater outfall at Nigran (Spain), where untreated effluent was discharged direct to the aquatic environment, contrary to the provisions of Article 4 of Directive 91/271/EEC;

(c)

the treatment plant for the Biguglia lagoons (France) did not meet the quality standards provided for in Annex I of the Directive. Further investment of the order of 22 Mio FF should be envisaged for this project, in order to bring it up to the standard required by the Directive.

The Community contribution for the above projects was around 7,2 Mio ECU. There are similar examples in the Cohesion Fund context, for example, operation of the Bassin d'Alviela sewage works (see also paragraph 41). Finance for modernising the plant was obtained through the Cohesion Fund. The Portuguese authorities informed the Commission that the quality criteria laid down by the Directive were not being met and introduced a further application for reprogramming, so that the requisite standards could be achieved. The plant is, in fact, too small in terms of the actual requirements of the area, where there is a high concentration of tanneries. The Community contribution to this project amounted to 4,9 Mio ECU.

62.

In conclusion, as the Court has already pointed out, it is regrettable that co-financed work on new sewage works was undertaken without taking account of the requirements imposed by this Directive (26). Even though these plants were built recently, the capital costs will be increased because of the additional work that will be needed in the short term, in order to bring them into line with the standards imposed by the Directive.

Project performance