, Special Report No 3/98 concerning the implementation by the Commission of EU policy and…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1998
76.

Monitoring discharges of treated water, whether discharged direct to the natural environment (where the Community standards are directly applicable) or into urban collection and treatment systems, is an important factor in combating water pollution. A national system of monitoring discharge conditions is provided in the operating licences which the Member States grant a priori for each classified installation. However, during the audit in Ireland of an agro-foodstuff project which received funds from EAGGF Guidance, the Court noted that the standards stipulated by the licence were not always observed, but no real sanctions were imposed (whether administrative or pecuniary), even though there was provision for them in the national regulations.

77.

These controls are exclusively the responsibility of national authorities. The Commission, for its part, should make provision for checks of this type during its audits in the Member States and should carry them out in order to satisfy itself that:

(a)

the chemical properties of the waste water intakes to treatment plants which receive industrial waste water are continuously monitored;

(b)

local authorities have full information concerning classified installations and the controls on discharges from them;

(c)

where Community financing is granted to public or private enterprises which produce waste water, the results of the controls carried out meet the standards laid down by the licences and Community directives.

The cost of projects - planned versus actual costs

78.

The technical weaknesses observed in the design and planning of projects give rise in most cases to incorrect estimates of the costs of the works that are to be carried out. The actual costs are substantially higher. In all Member States visited and for almost all projects audited significant cost differences were detected. The most important cases of underestimation of eligible expenditure observed by the Court are described in the following paragraphs.

79.

For the construction of the sewage plant of the Greater Athens Region in Psytalia (OP ERDF Attica axe 1.1.) at the time of the audit visit six main contracts - covering 77 % of the cost of the project - had been completed at a cost of approximately double the planned amount [from a planned ± 40,4 Mio ECU (11 500 Mio GRD) to ± 78,9 Mio ECU (22 400 Mio GRD)].