, Special Report No 3/98 concerning the implementation by the Commission of EU policy and…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1998
57.

Article 7 of Council Regulation (EEC) No 2081/93, concerning the Structural Funds, and Article 8 of the Cohesion Fund Regulation (25) state that the grant of Community aid is conditional on compliance with all the Community rules on the environment. This is emphasised in the water-treatment projects: the decisions to grant Cohesion Fund aid often refer to Directive 91/271/EEC. There are similar references in connection with various measures and sub-programmes that are being cofinanced as part of ERDF funding for the 1994-99 programming period. A clause of this type is important for compliance with Community law on the environment, but is pointless if the following conditions are not satisfied:

–

the clause must be coercive;

–

the Commission must have the means of carrying out compliance checks at the level of cofinanced projects.

58.

The obligation on Member States to comply with the terms of the Directive derives from Article 19 1, which specifies 30 June 1993 as the final date for compliance with the Directive. The provision in question applies to Member States, whether they have transposed the Directive or not. Projects cofinanced initially by the Financial Instrument and subsequently by the Cohesion Fund must comply with Directive 91/271/EEC, since both it and Council Regulation (EEC) No 792/93 on the Financial Instrument entered into force during 1993.

59.

As regards the Envireg CI, which was approved in May 1990, it was agreed in the framework of the negotiations between the Commission and the Member States that, as far as possible, projects involving treatment plants would comply with the terms of Directive 91/271/EEC. The following projects did not, however, comply:

(a)

the project concerning the underwater outfall at La Coruña (Spain) provided only pre-treatment, whereas the Directive requires secondary treatment;

(b)

the sewage plant at Funchal in Madeira (Portugal) was too small (it could only treat between 60 % and 70 % of the volume of sewage from the town) and was of the primary treatment type, whereas under the Directive it should be of the secondary type;

(c)

the discharge from the Mola di Bari (Italy) sewage plant did not meet the standards laid down by the Directive.

The Community contribution for these projects amounts to 12,7 Mio ECU.