, Special Report No 3/98 concerning the implementation by the Commission of EU policy and…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1998
94.

As regards the matter of public works contracts, the Court again found and pointed out to the Commission problems associated with excessive discounting of prices in order to secure contracts, as well as the use by some national administrations of various possibilities that are available under national law (emergency procedures and the like) and which aim to limit, or occasionally exclude, competition. Splitting up a project into several sub-projects and several public works contracts contributed to this situation. The Court noted that one Greek project financed by the ERDF (OP Attica, municipality of Perama) had been divided into 54 contracts. The total cost of this project was of the order of 457 207 ECU. Practices of this kind increase the delays in carrying out projects, swell the costs and render projects top-heavy. The Court has already noted that fact in a previous report (28).

95.

Project management frequently lacked transparency. For example, some projects - large ones in particular - had accumulated Community subsidies from various sources and, under current regulations, should have kept separate sets of accounts. At financial beneficiary level the various forms of assistance were, in the main, regarded as sources of finance to be used indiscriminately for the various phases of projects. This applied to IMP assistance in particular (IMP phase 1 IMP-related measures, IMP additional heading), or IOP for the projects audited in Corsica: Biguglia lagoon drainage works, drainage works on the south shore of the Gulf of Ajaccio.

96.

Similarly, the Court found that it was not always possible to reconcile the amounts of expenditure declared to the Commission by central administrations with those declared to national authorities by managers and/or beneficiaries. The main reason was the absence of separate accounts or an adequate account classification, which would have made it possible to identify the declared expenditure for the project that was being subsidised. This applied to the projects audited in Spain: collector GLI-3 Valladares-Lagares (Environment OP) and La Coruña underwater outfall (Envireg OP). Furthermore, as regards the waste water treatment measure in the Envireg-Stride Corsica programme, it was not possible to reconcile the declared expenditure with the evidence of payments disbursed by the final beneficiaries. These documents are, however, supposed to form the basis for certifying expenditure.

Malfunctioning treatment plants