The Court audited 67 projects involving the construction of waste water treatment plants and collection systems. Their total cost was approximately 467,7 Mio ECU and the European Union cofinancing was 291,7 Mio ECU (see Table 5). These projects were cofinanced by the ERDF, the Cohesion Fund, EAGGF Guidance and LIFE. In the following paragraphs the projects are examined for their contribution to the needs of the agglomerations served, the accuracy of the cost estimates and the eligibility of expenditure presented.
>TABLE>
Outdated design of projects
A large number of projects were designed a long time before their construction started and had not always been adapted to take account of population and pollution increases or technological changes.
As a consequence, these water treatment plants were, in most cases, of insufficient size or technical capacity to cover the needs of the agglomerations served. Such cases were identified by the Court in a number of Member States. In Greece a sewage plant was constructed without taking into account at the initial stage two closely situated local leather-processing industries, a slaughterhouse and the hotels being developed in the area. The effluent from these industries was discharged into the sea without any treatment. They are located at a distance of 400 m from the treatment plant. It was noted that the beneficiary had requested and received additional funds in order to link the polluter establishments with the treatment plant. The cost of this project is 6,1 Mio ECU.
The initial plans for the construction of a sewage plant in Italy dated from 1988 but the technical aspects of the project had to be revised because of budgetary restrictions, resulting in the construction of a plant with a treatment capacity that is inadequate for the needs of the town.
The Funchal-SRESA project, in Portugal, allowed only 60 to 70 % of the urban waste water to be treated. Moreover it was designed as a primary treatment plant, whereas it should have provided secondary treatment. The total cost was 9,6 Mio ECU.
In a collecting system and a sewage plant that were under construction in Galicia, the collectors designed were insufficient for the total volume of stormwater received. In addition, seawater was entering the main collector and causing problems to the functioning of the pumping stations. This will later affect the functioning of the sewage plant itself. The cost of the project was ± 4,7 Mio ECU.