In many of the Member States the use of treated sludge in agriculture presents problems concerning its quantity or its quality, as defined by the Regulations. In Brittany (France) sludge is used in addition to chemical fertilisers, which is contrary to the objective of the Directive in terms of pollution limits. In Corsica sludge, treated and untreated, is widespread in sites designated for public waste disposal. Failure to implement efficiently the Envireg measure on the elimination of solid waste - for which only 25 % of the appropriations allocated were used - has resulted in the deterioration of the solid waste situation on the island. This was also the case with a project in Portugal, where sludge was disposed of in the open, further increasing pollution.
At the water treatment plant of Alviela in Portugal the untreated sludge was being disposed of close to the centre of an olive grove. The treatment plant received its waste water from a large industrial complex where there were tanneries and the water contained large quantities of mercury.
In Ireland only 15 % of the total sludge produced was treated (32 000 tonnes in 1993). About 50 % of the untreated sludge was dumped at sea, aggravating the problems of coastal and marine pollution. In Galicia (Spain) and Corsica (France) sludge was also put in unsupervised and ill-prepared sites, with attendant risks to groundwater.
The issue of the use of sludge in agriculture is still controversial. In some regions in the Member States, for example Saxony, its use in agriculture is forbidden for those farmers who participate in the 'ecological agriculture programme`, and it is exported to other regions. In other cases where farmers are permitted to use sludge as a fertiliser, they are obliged to mention the fact when selling their produce. That provokes a negative effect in the market and farmers are more reluctant to use treated sludge for fertiliser, even if it is offered free of charge.
As with the nitrates Directive, the Commission has been able to complete some studies on this subject, but they have not been adequately publicised or exploited, neither at the Commission nor in the Member States. It has thus not been possible to demonstrate what the effects might be if farmers were to use sewage sludge as fertiliser.
CHAPTER II EU EXPENDITURE ON THE IMPROVEMENT OF WATER QUALITY
Budgetary implementation