, Special Report No 3/98 concerning the implementation by the Commission of EU policy and…

In forcesince 19 Mar 1998
91.

Irish projects also experienced delays in completion for the same reasons as in other Member States. Due to technical improvements a part of the Greystones project cofinanced by the ERDF was two years late in starting up. Delays were also observed in the Wexford Drainage Scheme project, where the start of construction of certain works of the Wexford Drainage Scheme was delayed for three years. The project only started in September 1993.

Management of projects by the responsible authorities

92.

The splitting-up of large projects sometimes makes it difficult to ensure that the provisions of the Structural and Cohesion Funds regulations are complied with. Article 1 3 of the Regulation establishing the Cohesion Fund (No 1164/94) provides for the possibility of financing projects in phases, provided that they are technically and financially independent. There were, however, some cases where projects which, in theory, could not be subdivided were nevertheless split, in order to obtain finance, first from the ERDF and then, subsequently, from the Cohesion Fund, as in the case of the Greystones Sewerage Scheme and Wexford Main Drainage Scheme projects which the Court audited in Ireland. Part of the financing for these projects was provided by the ERDF and, afterwards, by the Cohesion Fund, on the basis of the same contract with the enterprise instructed to carry out the actual works. It is difficult, therefore, for the project phases to be considered as independent projects; in reality they are only 'payment phases` and for practical purposes could be defined as the part of the project which has not yet received ERDF financing.

93.

This practice opens up the question of respect for and compliance with the Community regulations in this area. Moreover, there is a risk that breaking down projects into phases may make it easier to split up public works contracts in order to circumvent the limits stipulated in the various directives on the subject. The Court has mentioned this problem before, in Special report no 1/95 on the cohesion financial instrument (27).