, Decision_act (EU) 2001/88

In forcesince 21 Apr 1999

If we are to conclude that the capital injection under discussion was not State aid, it would have to be shown that the ABG behaved like a private investor in normal market conditions. The principles applied to determine whether a State-owned undertaking behaves like a private investor in market conditions are contained in the Commission communication to the Member States on the application of Articles 92 and 93 of the EEC Treaty and of Article 5 of Commission Directive 80/723/EEC (on the transparency of financial relations between Member States and public undertakings) to public undertakings in the manufacturing sector(7).

Examination of NFI's accounts reveals that the company in question began to show losses at least as early as 1992 and went on doing so until 1996, the year of the last balance sheet of which the Commission has a copy. There is, however, no evidence to suggest that the ABG, as investor, could have expected a satisfactory yield on its investment, since it had for many years let the company's position deteriorate without acting in any way.

Neither the Greek authorities nor the ABG have sent the Commission any detailed rationalisation plan such as should have been drawn up by the bank in order to restore NFI to long-term viability and which would have shown that the ABG's investment would produce a return. Furthermore, the Greek authorities have sent a copy of a study drawn up by the Ministry of Industry in 1994 on the productivity of the four fertiliser factories in Greece. The study lists NFI's problems and suggests a number of solutions.

The difficulties enumerated include the fact that part of the production units were shut down and stopped operating in 1991, the fact that following the upturn in fertiliser production in 1992, sales were too low to reach break-even point and, most of all, the GRD 4,5 billion debt which the National Electricity Board has been calling in.