, Decision_act (EU) 2001/88

In forcesince 21 Apr 1999

Since the condition that a restructuring plan to make the company viable again should be submitted to the Commission was not complied with, there is no need to examine the other conditions laid down by the guidelines. The aid measures in the form of guarantees cannot, therefore, be approved as restructuring aid.

(c)

Operating aid

The aid under consideration cannot be regarded as regional investment aid either, since the purpose of it was not to carry out productive investment. It must therefore be regarded as operating aid.

Operating aid may be granted only in the areas stated in Article 92(3)(a) of the Treaty. This article covers the whole territory of Greece. In its communication on the method for the application of Article 92(3)(a) and (c) to regional aid(14), the Commission accepts that operating aid may be given on certain conditions, as follows:

(i)

that the aid is limited in time and designed to overcome the structural handicaps of undertakings located in Article 92(3)(a) areas;

(ii)

that the aid is granted to promote the durable and balanced development of economic activity and does not lead to surplus production capacity in particular sectors at the Community level, such that the resulting Community sectoral problem is more serious than the original regional problem;

(iii)

that aid is not granted in violation of the specific rules on aid granted to companies in difficulty;

(iv)

that an annual report on how the aid is applied is sent to the Commission, showing total expenditure by type of aid and the sectors to which the aid relates;

(v)

that aid designed to promote exports to other Member States is excluded.

Having regard to what has been said above as regards the possibility of applying the Community guidelines on State aid for the rescuing and restructuring of companies in difficulty, the third condition has clearly not been met. It is also doubtful whether the aid can possibly promote the durable and balanced development of economic activity when it is borne in mind that, because there was no restructuring, there would obviously be a deterioration in the position of the company, even without considering the announcement that the factory was to shut down.