, Decision_act (EU) 2001/88

In forcesince 21 Apr 1999

The fact that Synel allows its suppliers different payment terms depending on the amounts of fertiliser purchased, and on the physical location of the suppliers, does not conflict with the rationale of the market. The distortion of competition to which the complainant refers clearly lies in the fact that certain suppliers, particularly PKT, sell their products at a loss.

This is confirmed by one of the interested third parties who submitted comments in the course of the procedure and who maintains that Synel's selling prices on the national market are directly linked to the prices charged by the suppliers.

The Commission reserves the right to investigate this point under any other provisions of the Treaty.

VI

In so far as it has been shown that the State aid for DF and the capital contribution to NFI constitute State aid within the meaning of Article 92(1) of the EC Treaty, it has now to be considered whether they were lawful and compatible with the common market.

All the above aid was granted to the two undertakings without the Commission being notified in advance, in violation of Article 93(3) of the Treaty. The aid is therefore found to be unlawful.

Compatibility of the aid in favour of DF

There were two aid measures, in the form of two State guarantees for loans of GRD 1.2 billion and GRD 600 million respectively.

(a)

Community rules on State aid for environmental protection

The Greek authorities consider that the aid measures in question are compatible with these rules(12), particularly section 3.4. This section provides that the Commission may make an exception to the general rule that it does not approve operating aid which relieves firms of costs resulting from the pollution or nuisance they cause. Such an exception can be made for example in fields such as waste management and relief from environmental taxes. In such cases, the aid must only compensate for extra production costs by comparison with traditional costs, and should be temporary and in principle degressive, so as to provide an incentive for reducing pollution or introducing more efficient uses of resources more quickly.

In their observations on the initiation of this procedure, the Greek authorities stated (in a letter dated 7 January 1997) that, since the factory is operating only temporarily, the object of the State contribution was to meet certain fixed operating costs, for environmental reasons, since the State itself has ordered a permanent reduction in production.