The aid in the form of State guarantees under consideration here cannot be regarded as rescue aid compatible with the guidelines, since it is not confined to whatever is essential to the running of the undertaking but covers part of the fixed costs and/or the operating losses, even if its purpose is to keep the recipient company viable.
In any case the aid greatly exceeds the time limit (generally speaking, six months) for the drafting of rationalisation measures under the guidelines in question. In this particular case, the guarantees covered loans for a period of two and a half years in the first instance and one and a half in the second, during which times no rationalisation measures whatever were drawn up or, at any rate, the Commission was not notified of anything to that effect.
Lastly, rescue aid must be an exceptional operation. In this case, however, the operation was repeated at least once, so as to cover losses over successive financial years.
As regards the compatibility of the aid as restructuring aid, it should be pointed out that the Commission was not notified of any restructuring plan which would have enabled the factory to be restored to long-term viability.
Furthermore, according to the information given in the Greek authorities' letter of 7 January 1997, it appears that the decision to close the factory's operations down for good had already been taken before the Prefecture of Piraeus issued its decision to that effect on 18 June 1997. Even before that decision was issued the letter referred to above states it as a given fact that the factory was merely operating on a temporary basis until the expected shutdown of operations in three or five years' time.
Both the Greek authorities and the complainant agree on at least one point, which is that the object of PKT was to develop land with a view to building. The purchase of the land on which the factory stands should logically be seen in conjunction with the business objectives of PKT, which wanted to use the land on which the factory had been built. It therefore makes no sense to refer to the long-term viability of the undertaking managing the factory (DF), since the undertaking itself was already in an extremely parlous condition and there were already plans to shut down operations and wind the company up. The fact that DF was placed in the hands of the receiver in 1997 seems the natural consequence of the condition the undertaking was in.