, Decision_act (EU) 2001/88

In forcesince 21 Apr 1999

The board of directors is elected freely and is controlled by the general meeting of shareholders. All the provisions entitling the State to appoint certain members of the board were repealed by Law No 2076/1992. The same law also repealed the provisions requiring public-sector organisations to be represented at the general meeting of shareholders by the Ministries of Finance, Labour, etc., or by a shared representative. Consequently, the Greek authorities maintain that it can no longer be argued that the acts of the bank's governing bodies are acts of the State. The bank's decisions do not, therefore, constitute State aid.

The Commission takes into account the composition of the bank's capital, the larger share of which belongs to the private sector. In so far as none of the information passed on to it shows that a majority of the members of the board of directors of the NBG are representatives of the public sector, the Commission concludes that the bank is not controlled by the Greek State.

The board of directors' decisions do not, therefore, fall within the scope of Article 92(1) of the Treaty. The Commission has already notified the Greek authorities of this conclusion, in the context of another case, on 24 April 1997. Consequently, neither the possible writing off of the GRD 9 billion debt in favour of AEEHPL nor the possible deferment of PKT's debt payments to the NBG - which the Greek authorities deny took place - constitutes a State aid measure. The Commission can therefore close the procedure in respect of those matters and of the loans granted to PKT and DF. It remains to be considered, however, whether the bank would have granted loans to those two firms if there had not been the State guarantees.

(b)

The State guarantees in favour of PKT and DF

These guarantees were given by ministerial decisions of 16 October 1995 and 16 January and 23 June 1996, and were published in the Greek Government Gazette(4). As these were ad hoc measures, they favour certain undertakings or certain production units within the meaning of Article 92(1) of the EC Treaty.