, Decision_act (EU) 2001/88

In forcesince 21 Apr 1999

It should also be noted that, in contrast to what happened with the State guarantee on the GRD 500 million loan in favour of PKT, there is no evidence that the Greek State required DF to take out a mortgage on all the Drapetsona Fertilisers factory's immovable property.

One might imagine PKT being guarantor for DF, for example mortgaging part of the abovementioned fixed property assets. That has been neither maintained nor demonstrated by the Greek authorities in the course of this procedure. One might in any case wonder how PKT would have given such a guarantee, when it was unwilling to offer security to the State in return for the State guarantee on the GRD 500 million loan referred to above.

As far as the NBG's notice of a charge on DF Ltd's property assets, to a value of GRD 5 billion, the documents produced by the Greek authorities show that the Mortgage Registry certified that on 17 July 1995 the NBG had a charge for that amount against the PKT, which was registered in 1994. The charge in question in no way relates to the property assets of DF, which had not yet been set up at that time.

The Greek authorities also explain that the grants of financing to PKT and, from 1996 onwards, DF by the NBG were made on the basis of financial and credit criteria of a purely bank-related kind. The terms (interest rates, security etc.) on the loans granted as working capital are those the NBG usually applies in respect of companies with a creditworthiness similar to that of the undertaking under consideration.

One might legitimately wonder what was the economic rationale behind these loans. The purpose of a grant of working capital to an undertaking is, in reality, to enable it to settle its current debts, not to carry out structural changes in order to improve its position. Furthermore, given that there were plans for the fertiliser factory to be closed down, it is doubtful whether other banking institutions would have made any long-term loans to DF.

In their letter of 21 November 1997, the Greek authorities say that: "with the guarantees it had been given for loans of GRD 1,2 billion and GRD 0,6 billion respectively, the Drapetsona factory took loans for those amounts from the NBG to cover its losses in 1994, 1995 and 1996".