, Decision_act (EU) 2001/88

In forcesince 21 Apr 1999

In so far as the purpose of the State intervention is to speed up the restructuring of the industry in question in Greece, while the process has already been carried through in the other Member States or is still under way in some of them, the Commission concludes that the aid distorts competition.

This view is shared by the interested third parties who have submitted comments, who have also stressed that they suffer from a comparative disadvantage compared with undertakings in receipt of aid, since State support enables the latter to carry on selling at a loss.

According to figures supplied by these third parties, which the Greek authorities have not disputed, the difficulties faced by PKT and DF did not prevent them (or NFI) from selling their output, in 1994 and 1995, at prices from 9 % to 25 % below the prevailing market prices. According to the same source, this was because the firms in question pursued a steady policy of systematically charging lower prices than those charged by other suppliers. It should not be forgotten that this grievance was among those which first prompted the complainant to act in this case.

It is therefore concluded that the aid in the form of State guarantees affects trade between the Member States. The State guarantees in favour of DF therefore constitute State aid caught by Article 92(1) of the EC Treaty.

Although this analysis is in itself sufficient to demonstrate that the measures under consideration are State aid, the Commission has felt it advisable to add further comments on certain contentions put forward by the Greek authorities. The Greek authorities do refer to figures which could be taken as grounds for supposing that the guarantees in question are not aid within the meaning of Article 92(1) of the Treaty. At no point, however, do they explicitly make any such assertion.

In their letter of 21 November 1997, the Greek authorities say that when DF was wound up its assets were sufficient, on being auctioned off, to cover not only its liabilities to the NBG but also its liabilities to third parties. Furthermore, again according to the Greek authorities, the objective value of DF's real estate and other immovable property came to GRD 16,34 billion. This is certified by a declaration submitted to the Piraeus Revenue Office.