, Decision_act (EU) 2001/88

In forcesince 21 Apr 1999

The 1995 balance sheet already shows that DF faced serious difficulties in repaying its bank loans, as the due date for repayment of a GRD 1,16 billion debt with a State guarantee had already arrived. This by itself represented 82 % of its short-term bank debt. There is no evidence that the remaining amount in short-term bank debts was not also covered by a State guarantee, nor have the Greek authorities put forward any such claim.

In view of the above, the Commission finds that the Greek authorities have failed to show that DF could have obtained loans to cover its operating losses in 1994, 1995 and 1996 without a guarantee from the Greek State.

As a result, the guarantees in question affect trade between the Member States and distort competition. They made it possible for the fertiliser factory to cope with the operating difficulties it was facing, while the cut in production capacity which the State imposed on it made it impossible for it to achieve sufficient sales to reach break-even point.

The guarantees under consideration consequently impede the natural restructuring of the industry in Greece, a process which has already taken place in most of the other Member States, since they temporarily and artificially keep alive a company which is incapable of showing a profit and is irrevocably required to go out of business in 2000. In addition, artificially keeping PKT and DF running makes it impossible for other national or Community producers to assume their share of the market. The guarantees under consideration therefore constitute aid within the meaning of Article 92(1) of the Treaty.

The Greek authorities have been unable to show in the course of this procedure that DF would have been able to obtain loans for the purpose of covering its operating losses in 1994, 1995 and 1996 without the State guarantee, primarily because of the extremely difficult financial position of the beneficiary company. No evidence has emerged during the examination procedure to overturn the view stated when the procedure was launched, that the guarantees coincide with the amount guaranteed minus 1 % commission on the amount of the loan, paid in order to secure the guarantee.