the way in which the terms of the financing agreements are interpreted does not provide the basis for a positive conclusion regarding the justification for 87 Mio ECU of payments relating to structural adjustment (paragraph 3.72);
in the case of the 3,6 Mio ECU of interest subsidy payments examined, the supporting documents available at the Commission constitute insufficient evidence to justify the amounts calculated by the EIB and passed to the accounts by the Commission (paragraph 3.77);
the rules were not applied in the case of 18 Stabex payments totalling 216 Mio ECU, 163,4 Mio ECU of which was disbursed although the beneficiary State had not submitted a report on the use of the resources transferred (paragraph 3.73); 75 Mio ECU was paid without prior substantial analysis and 31,1 Mio ECU was based on insufficient substantive analysis (paragraph 3.74), whilst there was insufficient justification for 101,5 Mio ECU in the calculation of transfer base reductions (paragraph 3.75);
payments amounting to 12,2 Mio ECU were made despite the fact that the rules and contractual conditions, the payment deadlines (paragraphs 3.79 - 3.80) and the performance deadlines (paragraph 3.78) had not been observed. For one payment of 0,5 Mio ECU the Court was unable to obtain the supporting documents needed to justify the revised prices charged on invoices (paragraph 3.76).
3.10. The known value of the year's commitments affected by formal legality/regularity errors is 87,2 Mio ECU:
an amount of 9 Mio ECU by way of additional structural adjustment support financed through national indicative programmes was authorized according to a procedure which is reserved for traditional types of development project (paragraph 3.66). There were a further two cases, for a total of 26,6 Mio ECU (paragraph 3.67), where the EDF Committee did not have sufficient information. In another case, involving an amount of 9,2 Mio ECU, the commitment was entered into before the necessary appropriations had been made available (paragraph 3.68);
the supporting documents held by the Commission are insufficient evidence to justify an amount of 37 Mio ECU in commitments and interest subsidies which were calculated by the EIB and passed to the accounts by the Commission (paragraph 3.69).
the supporting documents did not provide the Court with positive evidence of the justification for reducing the transfer base for one Stabex commitment of 5,5 Mio ECU (paragraph 3.70).