, Special Report in support of the Statement of Assurance concerning the activities of the…

In forcesince 28 Oct 1996

Reservations concerning the accounts

3.4. Certain Court findings (for example points 3.4(b) and 3.4(d)) are a normal consequence of the way the EDF is administered; the presentation of the operations cited follows generally accepted accounting principles.

Moreover, in the Commission's opinion, the problems raised cannot be solved merely by amending its current accounting procedures.

(a)

The problem of overestimation of commitments raised by the Court is a question of project management, not accounting methods and practices. Projects can only be closed or reduced on a proposal from the national authorizing officer. The accounts record amendments legally accepted by the parties. The Commission considers that at the closure of the 1995 financial year, the accounts were a faithful reflection of legal commitments.

The Commission does not wish to introduce partial decommitment procedures systematically for projects in progress. The Commission decommits the sums remaining at the closure of a project, once the exact amount is known. The cases of this type examined by the Court accounted for ECU 32.8 million. However, the Commission is not opposed to the introduction of a revision clause in financing agreements.

Moreover, in the absence of a request from the EIB, the Commission was not entitled to close the accounts for the ECU 37 million of EIB operations referred to by the Court.

However, the Commission has a system to identify commitments likely to be closed, which has already made it possible to decommit large sums. The Court's estimate of primary commitments yet to be paid that no longer reflect the economic reality of operations represents 3.6% of the commitments still unsettled, i.e. 1.2% of the primary commitments posted.

(b)

Advances are made available to management agencies for the payment of study grants and technical assistance contracts in progress. Documentary proof is supplied to the Commission at regular intervals. Upon closure of the account, there is therefore an outstanding debt corresponding to any advances paid and not yet justified.

These uncleared advances are presented on the assets side of the balance sheet at the closure of the accounts, in accordance with generally accepted accounting standards.

(c)

Advances paid in connection with structural adjustment currency programmes and contracts and estimates concluded by ACP States are presented in the financial statements as payments for projects, which is an accurate reflection of the reality.