The Commission has already given detailed explanations on this point in response to the special report in support of the 1994 DAS (points 3.40 to 3.42). However, it reaffirms that with regard to balance of payments support:
the final use of these funds is their transfer to the recipient State;
the transfers themselves are final;
the funds deposited in ECU accounts in Europe and the counterpart funds are the property of the beneficiary State.
However, for the sake of transparency, and despite being under no statutory obligation to do so, the Commission does publish tables in the financial statements showing how much of the funds deposited in Europe and counterpart funds have been mobilized.
To give a clearer idea of the balance of counterpart funds yet to be mobilized, the Commission will convert the amounts into ecus.
3.47. The Commission wishes to stress that the Court's observation applies only to the way the funds transferred are entered into the accounts.
In terms of their management, the Commission always applies Article 250(3), checking that the tranche transferred has been used before proceeding to transfer the next tranche.
Article 250(3) of the Convention only applies to programmes and estimates, not to direct procurement programmes. The accounts traditionally record these transfers as advances. The Commission will see to it in future that this method of accounting is always adopted.
3.49. The Commission identifies and attributes any losses or profits to particular projects where it can. Where this is impossible, the amounts are posted in the financial expenses account. The Commission will consider this question with a view to improving the audit trail.
3.50. The Commission agrees with the Court and will show this breakdown in future financial statements.
Advances on contracts
3.51 to 3.53. The Commission does not view the payment of an advance as a final payment, since it is subject to follow-up and subsequent clearance. Moreover, the financial statements show advances as payments on projects, which reflects what they are.
As to the presentation of the utilization of funds in the financial statements, the Financial Regulation provides for payments to be shown without any distinction between advances and instalments.
However, the Commission acknowledges that it would be useful to have an annex to the financial statements showing advances.