, Special Report in support of the Statement of Assurance concerning the activities of the…

In forcesince 28 Oct 1996
(a)

3,75 Mio ECU of payments without supporting documents (paragraph 3.27(b) and 3.27(c));

(b)

0,7 Mio ECU of revenue for which there are no supporting documents (paragraph 3.27(b));

(c)

1,5 Mio ECU of unjustified adjustments to the bank balances (paragraph 3.27(a)).

3.59. In the Court's opinion these transactions should be explained when the Commission grants final discharge to the EDF accounting officer pursuant to the provisions of Article 43 of the Financial Regulation for the seventh EDF.

Payments

3.60. Contracts set out the procedures for both the payment of advances and their subsequent recovery. Among the payments examined, five relating to works contracts were for the wrong amount because the advance that had been paid earlier had not been recovered correctly. Notwithstanding the correction of these errors in subsequent payments relating to the same contracts, the individual payments examined are 2,3 Mio ECU too high.

3.61. In another case relating to an emergency-aid operation, an advance of 70% amounting to 0,35 Mio ECU was granted, by derogation from the normal ceiling of 50%, without establishing the existence of conditions which make such a derogation possible (20% or 0,1 Mio ECU).

3.62. In the case of one payment on account relating to a technical assistance contract the retention money had been deducted twice. The financial impact of this error is around 0,01 Mio ECU.

3.63. The eligibility of the payments of 4 Mio ECU made in December 1995 in connection with the increase in the ceiling on a financing agreement relating to structural adjustment in Niger is just as questionable as the increase in the corresponding commitments (paragraph 3.57), and the remarks concerning conditionality made in paragraph 3.77 are equally relevant in this case.

3.64. The general terms and conditions for service contracts which entered into force on 1 June 1991 () have considerably amended the conditions that applied previously. Article 35(4), in particular, stipulates that an advance payment may not exceed 90% of the value of the services to which it relates and does not provide for any derogation from this regulation by either the contracts or the special conditions. The provisions concerning retention money are considered by the Commission departments to be inappropriate to certain types of contract, e.g. contracts carried out by government agencies, as in the case of technical assistance. As a general rule there is no retention money on these contracts.