, Special Report in support of the Statement of Assurance concerning the activities of the…

In forcesince 28 Oct 1996

3.74. Article 209 of the Convention also stipulates that States receiving Stabex transfers must present the Commission with a substantiating report on the sectors affected by falls in revenue. No such report was supplied in the case of eight of the Stabex payments reviewed, which accounted for 75 Mio ECU. In four other cases, totalling 31,2 Mio ECU, the document presented and accepted by the Commission was too vague to be used as a substantiating report within the meaning of Article 209.

3.75. No reductions were applied to the transfer base for seven Stabex payments reviewed by the Court amounting to 101,5 Mio ECU. The Court is unable to evaluate the justification for these measures from the supporting documents available.

3.76. With regard to one payment of 0,54 Mio ECU relating to a works contract, the supporting documents do not contain any details that allow the calculation of the price revision to be checked, even though it accounts for 93% of the invoices in question. As the documentation requested by the Court in January 1996 was not supplied, the Court was unable to check the validity of the calculation. For this contract alone, which had a value of 21,2 Mio ECU, the Court estimates that some 8 Mio ECU has already been paid by way of price revisions alone.

3.77. Just like the corresponding commitments, payments of interest-rate subsidies are entered in the accounts on the basis of information supplied by the EIB, which does not make it possible to check whether the calculations for the loan account were in accordance with the provisions of Article 60(3) of the Financial Regulation. The same uncertainty applies to all the interest-subsidy payments for the financial year, which amount to 21,5 Mio ECU, in addition to the four cases identified in the sample of payments totalling 3,6 Mio ECU.

3.78. There were three payments for a total of 0,4 Mio ECU, also connected with services contracts, where there had been delays in the performance of the related contract. However, the contracts had not been formally amended to cover the extra time allowed by the Commission.