In the case of Saint Vincent and the Grenadines, the period of drought in question lasted from late 1993 until August 1994, so that its impact on falling output was greater than the Court appears to think, particularly as there was less scope for reviving production in the four months following the drought. This was made clear in the Delegation's note of 17 May 1995, which was one of the documents supporting the transfer. In accordance with the manual for Stabex recipients, the reduction is not as a rule applied in the event of natural disasters.
The Commission is of the view that these cases were sufficiently well-documented.
3.76. The Commission cannot confirm the Court's estimate of the value of price revisions as ECU 3 million, since this would require it to apply the real exchange rates prevailing at the time of payments including price revisions.
Commission officials' failure to reply arose from a misunderstanding regarding the Court's request.
3.77. The Commission reiterates that it is not responsible for the management of EIB operations and is therefore not competent to conduct checks on them (see point 3.69). The Commission takes the Court's observation to reflect the audit's constraints (point 2 of the report) rather than a criticism addressed to the Commission with a view to the DAS.
With regard to the payments examined by the Court, the Commission confirms that details of the calculations appear in the payment file. However, the Commission is willing to supply, on request, any document the Court deems necessary.
3.78. In the three cases to which the Court refers, the delays in submitting the interim reports were the fault of the contracting authority and not the contractor.
The Commission believes that intermediate deadlines should not be subject to formal riders to the contract, especially since the contracts do not impose any penalties for failing to meet them. It considers such changes to be a prerogative of contract management, which should be flexible. However, in the three cases cited, the alterations were documented in correspondence with the contractor.
3.79. In the Commission's view, delays in payment must be assessed in terms of the difference between the date of the request for payment and the value date of the debit in the EDF accounts.