Nonetheless, the advance of 70% of the value of the contract was approved in February 1995 in view of the indicative timetable which provided for release of ECU 358 000 by the end of 1995. The use-of-funds report supplied to the Commission by the NGO in question in May 1996 shows that all the funds were disbursed.
3.62. The retention money was indeed deducted twice and the payment was underestimated to the tune of around ECU 9 500.
However, this anomaly was spotted by the official in charge of authorizing the expenditure, and corrected when the following payment was made, which illustrates that the internal checks introduced by the Commission do work.
3.63. See the Commission's replies in point 3.57.
3.64 and 3.65. The Commission views technical assistance contracts (carried out by government agencies) as contracts executed incrementally, the work being approved by the contracting authority as and when it settles the invoices received for the hours worked. Retention money is not consistent with final acceptance of each stage of work. The contracting authority could hardly withhold retention money on grounds of poor performance if it has accepted the services as and when they were provided.
The Commission therefore allows the ACP authorities to negotiate special conditions derogating from the general conditions (the three cases in which the Court estimates that some ECU 20 500 was overpaid () are therefore legitimate under the contract) or to authorize 100% of the value of the services provided (as in the case of the two payments in which the Court maintains that ECU 20 000 was overpaid). ()The Commission does not accept that there is no retention money 'as a rule`; some technical assistance contracts are negotiated with 10% withheld, and the payments are therefore authorized in accordance with that provision.
Formal legality/regularity errors
Decisions (primary commitments)
3.66. Financing decisions for structural adjustment programmes financed from national indicative programmes may be subject to increases decided by the chief authorizing officer as long as the increase does not exceed 20% of the initial commitment (Article 292 of the Convention and Article 62 of the Financial Regulation).
Failing a similar procedure for structural adjustment programmes financed from the structural adjustment instrument, the Commission applies the procedure described above, by analogy.