Article 60(2) of the Financial Regulation states: 'On the signing of each loan contract, the Bank shall communicate to the Commission the estimated total amount of the interest rate subsidy expressed in ECU.` No approval is provided for. This document has long provided the basis for the commitment of funds in the EDF accounts. The contract signed by the parties is received by the Commission some days later.
The EIB accepts responsibility for evaluating the interest rate subsidy granted to the borrower, in accordance with the Convention, the Internal Agreement and the Financial Regulation. The texts do not provide for verification of the EIB estimates by the Commission. Their accuracy is ensured by internal and external control procedures for which the EIB itself is responsible.
2.The EIB estimate is governed by provisions in the loan contract. The estimate will not be changed unless other provisions are changed, for example, a change in the transfer date or early repayment of the loan.
The Commission's view is that any inaccuracy in estimating the interestrate subsidy does not impinge upon the legality of the underlying transactions.
3.The Commission takes the Court's observation to reflect the audit's constraints (point 2 of the report) rather than a criticism addressed to the Commission with a view to the DAS.
3.70. The Commission considers the reduction in the transfer basis was justified. The Court's comment arises from a comparison between two ACP States in different circumstances. The reduction in the transfer basis was not proportional because:
the precipitation factor was greater in the case of the second ACP State;
certain factors explaining the drop in production (the poor quality of the seed and the lack of it) resulted directly from the 1993 drought (the second worst on record since 1960, in terms of rainfall), which forced farmers to tap their seed stocks for groundnuts for consumption;
this phenomenon had a knock-on effect on producers' incomes, leaving them without the means to obtain fertilizers.
Consequently, the Commission does not consider the commitment to have been overestimated.
Payments