, Special Report in support of the Statement of Assurance concerning the activities of the…

In forcesince 28 Oct 1996
(i)

On the subject of consultations between the Commission and some ACP States, these may of course be influenced by the States' capacity and speed of response, given the strict deadlines imposed by the Convention.

(ii)

Since the consultations cover countries facing different circumstances, the Commission views as arbitrary the tendency to draw comparisons supposedly proving that one country has not been treated in the same way as another.

(iii)

While Article 203 lays down the circumstances requiring consultations, it does not suggest that the outcome should be automatic; the Commission is therefore entitled to suppose that certain situations, for example those of countries emerging from a period of dictatorship with their economies wrecked, may legitimately be taken into consideration.

In short, the Commission would point out that it will continue to be as objective as possible, as regards consultations under Article 203, taking into account the diversity of the countries and situations concerned. To this end, the Commission has made greater use of the delegations since the 1993 application year, as a way of ensuring that the consultations take place on the basis of the most accurate information possible.

In the case of Uganda, coffee prices were very low in 1992, so it was quite proper that the reduction imposed as a result of falling commercial output was not applied in full.

In Kenya's case, the substantial analysis was not the only document on which the consultations were based. From information in the file one may infer that cyclical drought affects commercial production.

As regards Haiti, the non-application of the reduction with regard to the fall in exports was explained by a number of factors outside the Government's control, such as disease, soil erosion and falling world prices. Moreover, in that particular case the Commission was concerned to avoid penalizing the country for the political situation prior to 1990, which had caused massive economic damage.

With reference to Senegal, see the Commission's reply in point 3.70.