The Commission takes the Court's observation to reflect the audit's constraints (point 2 of the report) rather than a criticism addressed to the Commission with a view to the DAS.
With regard to the payments examined by the Court, the Commission confirms that details of the calculations are given in the payment dossier. However, the Commission is willing to supply, on request, any document the Court deems necessary.
The Commission does not share the Court's interpretation of Article 212 of the Convention. There may be valid reasons for an ACP State's failure to produce a report on time, or at all, such as delays or blockages in the implementation of the framework of mutual obligations. The Commission considers the payments cited by the Court to be in order, as the Convention allows the Commission some discretion on late reports or failure to report (see point 3.73).
The substantial analysis of the relevant sector which the ACP State is required to produce is not a condition of payment but merely one of the assessment factors used to calculate the transfer basis. The payments are therefore in order (see point 3.74).
The amounts are calculated in consultation with the ACP States under Article 203 of the Convention. The Commission considers that the details given in the calculations provide sufficient justification for the ECU 101.5 million (see the Commission's comments in point 3.75).
Apart from delays in three payments totalling ECU 1 million, referred to in point 3.80, the Commission shares neither the Court's assessment of payment delays for EIB interest rate subsidies (point 3.79), nor its stance as to the need formally to amend the contracts to cover the extra time allowed by the Commission for submission of interim reports (point 3.78).
The Commission's failure to reply concerning the revised prices for a payment of ECU 0.5 million arose from a misunderstanding with regard to the Court's request.
3.10 (a) The Commission acknowledges that, in the absence of any specific procedure, decisions on additional financing for structural adjustment programmes financed under the structural adjustment facility (point 3.66) have merely followed the procedure for projects financed under the national indicative programme. This arrangement has been formalized in the Internal Agreement on the eighth EDF.