, Special Report in support of the Statement of Assurance concerning the activities of the…

In forcesince 28 Oct 1996

Note, too, that it can often take over a year to implement the framework of mutual obligations, the ACP States concerned cannot possibly present a full report as required under Article 212, only an interim report (or more than one), with the final report being drafted only after the programmes and operations set out in the framework are completed.

The Commission would also point out the ACP States' reports under Article 212(1) are purely factual. Since the fourth Lomé Convention entered into force, the Commission has carried out a major programme of evaluations of the use of Stabex transfers by each ACP State. These evaluations show that the new provisions of the fourth Convention on dual-signature accounts and frameworks of mutual obligations provide the best guarantees on the use of Stabex transfers that one could wish for.

3.74. The timetable established in the Convention provides for the Commission to notify the States of the situation regarding possible transfers in late April. Consequently, ACP States have only one month to carry out the substantial analysis required and submit it to the Commission.

Under those circumstances, it is questionable whether any exercise which was seriously required to meet such a tight deadline would be genuinely productive. While the substantial analysis is useful, in that it provides a nucleus of ideas to be developed in drafting the framework of mutual obligations subject to subsequent negotiation, one cannot realistically expect ACP States to supply the analysis within the time limit. Consequently, Article 209(1) needs to be interpreted loosely.

The Court makes a connection between the substantial analysis (Article 209) and the consultations provided for in Article 203 in the event of significant changes in the ACP State's eligible production or exports. The Commission acknowledges that some information in the substantial analysis may be taken into account in deciding upon reductions in the transfer basis under that Article; however, payment is not conditional on the substantial analysis.

Recourse to Article 203 also (and often primarily) arises from the appraisal procedure for transfer cases, and exchanges of information between the delegations and the department in charge of the system, which have expanded considerably in recent application years, following observations made by the Court in its special report on Stabex.

3.75. The Commission wishes to add clarifications on the following points: