, Decision_act (EU) 1999/718

In force

Spain has communicated an extremely detailed report, drawn up by the Basque regional authorities, on the basis and workings of the tax arrangements applicable in the Province of Álava. The report claims that, when it decided to initiate proceedings, the Commission did not take sufficient account of the historical, constitutional and legislative bases of the Province's specific legal arrangements.

In the taxation field in particular, the reference framework for these special arrangements is the Economic Agreement referred to in point II.5.

Using these legislative powers in the tax field, the Álava Provincial Council adopts, among other things, legal provisions relating to corporation tax.

The regional authorities consider that these corporation tax provisions are general measures which should not be examined in the light of Article 92 of the Treaty since they lay down the general corporation tax arrangements applicable in the Province of Álava. According to the Basque regional authorities, in taking the view that these arrangements could involve aid, in so far as the tax concessions they provide for are restricted to companies established in or maintaining economic links with part of the territory of a Member State, the Commission is failing to take into consideration the specific structure of taxation powers under Spanish law.

Neither is the tax credit in particular granted on a discretionary basis by the Álava Provincial Council. The tax credit is governed by law and granted automatically to eligible firms. The regional authorities stress that it is not possible under Spanish law to apply differentiated tax treatment, except in cases expressly provided for by law. Indeed, individual tax measures are prohibited. In the case of the tax credit, the Basque authorities do not enjoy any discretionary powers whatsoever. The decision to grant the tax credit (Decision 737/97) referred to in the legislation concerned merely involves a prior check that the eligibility conditions are fulfilled and is adopted for reasons of legal certainty and sound financial management. A company merely has to demonstrate that there is a causal link between the investments made during the preparatory phase of the project and the materialisation of those investments in order to qualify for the tax credit.