the household-appliances sector is of strategic importance for the Basque Country. The regional authorities base their arguments concerning the strategic nature of the sector on the theory of competitive advantage and clusters(20). They claim that the household appliances cluster accounts for 6 % of GDP in the region and can consequently be regarded as strategic; the project is furthermore strategic in its own right since Demesa's establishment in the Basque Country will lead to keener competition between companies in a sector in which there is no strong group of local competitors in the region,
a multinational company was investing in a region severely affected by economic recession,
the grant awarded to Demesa does not exceed the ceiling of 25 % gge laid down in the Ekimen aid scheme, which in turn represents only around 20 % nge. This is less than the maximum allowed in the Basque Country (25 % nge),
the fact that the investment is not located in a preferential interest area for the purposes of the Ekimen scheme does not mean that Demesa cannot be awarded aid up to the prescribed maximum of 25 % gge: the regional authorities enjoy wide discretionary powers allowing them to award grants up to that limit,
there is no objective factual basis for the complainant's claim that the real cost of Demesa's investment is only half the declared value. The regional authorities nevertheless decided to carry out an audit on the investments made,
the Ekimen scheme comprises a procedure for checking and monitoring investments which makes it possible at all times to verify that the investments actually made correspond to the amount of aid disbursed.
2. Observations submitted by Spain
2.1. Free-of-charge use of a 500000 m2 plot of land and subsequent sale of the land at less than the market price
The regional authorities claim that Demesa has never used a 500000 m2 plot of land free of charge. With the aid of documentary evidence, they point out that the company occupied and subsequently purchased a plot of only 100000 m2. In line with specific requirements of property law, the sale was formalised only after successive divisions and amalgamations of the different pre-existing plots had been completed. The regional authorities have also supplied aerial photographs demonstrating that Demesa has indeed occupied only the 100000 m2 of land it purchased.