The 45 % tax credit in question undoubtedly fulfils this criterion since, thanks to the credit, Demesa enjoys a reduction in its tax burden equivalent to 45 % of the amount of the investment as determined by the Álava Provincial Council. The tax credit can, however, be used without any time-limit, starting in the first year in which the company makes a profit. The Spanish authorities have furthermore confirmed(48) that Demesa will be able to choose, in respect of each tax year, the most favourable methods of deduction or reduction, which makes it impossible in practice to determine the intensity of the aid over the whole period in which it is being received.
Second, the advantage must be granted by the State or through State resources. A loss of tax revenue is equivalent to the use of state resources in the form of tax expenditure. This criterion also applies to aid granted by regional or local bodies in the Member States (judgment of the Court of Justice of 14 October 1987 in Case 248/84 Germany v Commission(49)). The State aid may furthermore be granted by way of tax measures laid down by law, regulation or administrative practice or by way of decisions taken by the tax administration.
The tax credit granted to Demesa derives from the combined effect of a budgetary measure and an individual decision (Decision 737/97), both taken by a public authority.
Third, the measure must affect competition and trade between Member States. This criterion presupposes that the beneficiary of the measure carries on an economic activity, irrespective of its legal status or method of financing. The Court of Justice has repeatedly ruled, for the purposes of interpreting this condition, that intra-Community trade is to be deemed to be affected from the moment the beneficiary firm carries on an economic activity which is the subject of trade between Member States.
It has already been demonstrated that Demesa carries on an economic activity which is the subject of trade between member States, in a sector that is highly competitive.