A complication nevertheless arose in the course of the sale transaction owing to the presence on the land of tenant farmers who claimed compensation for crops ploughed up as a result of the construction work. It was only after enforcement proceedings had been initiated, and subsequently settled out of court, that the deed of sale was formalised on 30 December 1997. According to the regional authorities, the transfer of ownership could not take place until the dispute over tenure of the land had been resolved, since Gazteiko Industria Lurra SA, the company selling it, felt bound to act in good faith towards the purchaser. In any event, the regional authorities stress that the sale took place in accordance with Spanish law and therefore that there can be no question of aid as far as the conditions of sale are concerned.
As regards the price at which the land was sold, the average prices communicated by the complainant (between ESP 6000 and ESP 7000 per square metre) are for plots of land (between 1000 and 10000 m2) much smaller than that purchased by Demesa (100000 m2). It is reasonable to assume that a lower price per square metre would be charged for a plot of land 10 times larger. In support of this, the regional authorities have submitted two reports drawn up after the sale by two independent experts, according to which the purchase price of a 100000 m2 plot of serviced land varies between ESP 4000 and ESP 5000 per square metre. The regional authorities consequently take the view that the price of ESP 4125 per square metre of serviced land paid by Demesa is in line with market conditions.
The documentation submitted also includes a "supplementary accounting report on available plots of land" drawn up, according to the regional authorities, by the auditors Price Waterhouse for 1997. That report gives a unit cost of ESP 4481 per square metre of serviced land for 50000 m2 plots located in the same area as the land occupied by Demesa.
Lastly, the regional authorities take the view that the Commission communication of 10 July 1997 on State aid elements in sales of land and buildings by public authorities(21) does not apply to the case in point since the purchase of the land was decided before the communication was adopted.
2.2. Tax aid