Decision 737/97 granted Demesa a tax credit of this nature amounting to 45 % of the value of the investments. The tax credit cannot be combined with any other tax concession granted in respect of the same investments.
The regional authorities have submitted a report stating that the tax burden is heavier in the Basque Country than in the rest of Spain, despite a tax rate which is 2,5 percentage points lower and the tax concessions available only in that region(22).
3. Observations submitted by interested parties
A number of observations were received from the complainants concerning the initiation of proceedings. These can be summarised as follows:
the Spanish authorities were deliberately slow in answering the Commission's successive letters, pursuing a policy of fait accompli. The complainants point out that the first substantial answer to the Commission's first request for information, which dated from June 1996 (when it was still possible to take action to prevent disbursement of the aid) was not received until 11 February 1997,
the household appliances sector, and particularly the refrigerators/freezers segment, continues to suffer from surplus capacity. Three of the leading European manufacturers (Electrolux, Whirlpool and Fagor) have announced plant closures and job cuts or restructuring operations. The complainants stress in this connection that the Court of Justice of the European Communities confirmed in Pyrsa (judgment of 14 January 1997 in Case C-169/95 Spain v Commission)(23) that regional aid should not give rise to a sectoral overcapacity,
the conditions for the award of the grant have not been fulfilled, since:
the project will not be completed within three years,
the project is not "strategic", nor will it entail the "creation of jobs". Only a grant of 10 % gge would be justified in accordance with the criteria laid down for the Ekimen scheme,
the tax credit is illegal since it was not notified to the Commission before it was put into effect,
Demesa is occupying a 500000 m2 plot of land without legal title and without paying rent. Free-of-charge use of the land is worth ESP 100 million per year, and the price of land in the same area is around ESP 6000 per square metre,
the cost of the plant and machinery has been overvalued, with the result that the amount of the grant corresponds to 51 % of the real cost of the investments,