However, the first valuation stated that the selling price of a serviced plot of over 10000 m2 should be between ESP 4000 and ESP 4500 per square metre. The second valuation, based on real data - that is to say the selling prices of serviced plots with similar characteristics sold in previous months - established a price of ESP 5000 per square metre for two much larger plots of approximately 33000 m2; and 50000 m2, and concluded that there were no price indicators on the market for serviced plots of 100000 m2; however, a price of between ESP 4000 and ESP 4800 per square metre appeared justified in the circumstances, given the costs that could be incurred in servicing large plots. It stressed at the same time the political dimension of sales of this type, which were bound to be influenced by non-economic considerations.
The audit report drawn up in July 1998 (see Annex IV to the letter of 24 July 1998) quoted the price of a non-serviced plot in the same area at around ESP 5000 per square metre. It stated that the price paid by Demesa could be justified by a discount offered on account of the size of the plot. Nevertheless, in his conclusions, the auditor maintains a price of ESP 5000 per square metre and points to the difference between his estimate and the price of ESP 4125 per square metre set by the regional authorities.
The Commission notes that the average of these estimates does not differ substantially from the average unit price of ESP 4481 per square metre of serviced land calculated in January 1997 by Price Waterhouse, which includes development costs.
In the light of the foregoing, the Commission considers that this price of ESP 4481 per square metre is the market price for the sale of plots similar to the one occupied by Demesa in the Júndiz industrial estate. Given that Demesa paid only ESP 4125 per square metre for the land, it enjoyed an advantage that must be calculated as the difference between the two figures, namely ESP 356 per square metre, making a total of EUR 213960,31 (ESP 35600000). This price difference constitutes state aid within the meaning of Article 92(1) of the Treaty.
2.3. Aid elements not covered by the Ekimen scheme
Amount of the grant