, Decision_act (EU) 1999/718

In force
–

The price of non-serviced land in the Júndiz industrial estate (Vitoria-Gasteiz) is ESP 5000 per square metre; the final price of ESP 4125 per square metre paid by Demesa for serviced land is a market price with a normal discount given the size of the plot. The report's findings examine the differences between the estimates made by the consultant and the regional authorities (the column "Consultant's estimate" gives a price for the land of ESP 500 million (or ESP 5000 per square metre), whereas the column "Demesa" shows a price of ESP 413 million(24) (or ESP 4125 per square metre)),

–

the cost of the buildings and construction work is in line with prices prevailing in the construction industry,

–

>TABLE>

–

there is no justification for claiming ESP 525 million in installation costs and costs prior to start-up.

The report also states that current production capacity is 140000 refrigerator units of between 310 and 370 litres. There are plans for raising capacity to 600000 units in future. To reach that level of output, it would be necessary, according to the auditor, to add an extra production line and create two shifts or to build a new factory with the same capacity.

IV.

2. Observations submitted by interested parties

The new points made by interested parties in the observations they submitted can be summarised as follows:

–

the argument put forward by the Basque regional authorities, according to which, in order to boost competition in the sector, it is necessary to subsidise a competitor, is incoherent, contrary to common sense and does not make the project at all strategic. Competition does exist on the Spanish market. This argument would make sense only if the relevant geographic market were the market of the Basque Country, and if that market were protected; however, the relevant geographic market is the European market,

–

the jobs created are insecure and extremely low-paid(25),

–

if the forecasts are fulfilled, Demesa will place an extra 600000 units on the European market, thereby contributing to an aggravation of the surplus capacity estimated at 5 million units.

For these reasons, and in view of the seriousness of the situation, the interested parties requested the Commission to order the provisional recovery of the aid paid to Demesa, pending adoption of the final decision.

IV.

3. Comments made by Spain in response to observations submitted by interested parties