This Decision relates only to those tax measures explicitly examined herein and does not pass judgment on the other measures provided for by the specific tax arrangements adopted in the Province of Álava. The Commission reserves the right to examine any such measures that might constitute aid, either as general schemes, or in so far as they might be applied to Demesa.
CONCLUSIONS
The Commission finds that Spain has acted illegally and in breach of Article 93(3) of the Treaty in granting the following aid:
the advantage equivalent to postponement of payment of the price of a plot of land in the Júndiz industrial estate at Vitoria-Gasteiz for a period of nine months, running from the time at which Demesa first occupied the land for the purpose of carrying out construction work (February 1997) until the date on which it paid the price (no earlier than November 1997), the amount of which is calculated at EUR 184075,79 (ESP 30627635);
the advantage equivalent to the difference between the market price and the price paid by Demesa for a plot of land in the Júndiz industrial estate, the amount of which is calculated at EUR 213960,31 (ESP 35600000);
the amount corresponding to the five percentage points that exceed the maximum permissible grant of 20 % of eligible costs under the Ekimen aid scheme, namely the plant valued at EUR 1803036,31 in the audit report submitted by the regional authorities as an annex to Spain's letter of 24 July 1998;
the grant of a tax credit corresponding to 45 % of the cost of the investment as determined by the Álava Provincial Council in Decision 737/1997 of 21 October 1997;
the reduction in the tax base for newly created businesses provided for by Article 26 of Provincial Law 24/1996.
This aid has to be deemed incompatible with the common market. Consequently, in order to re-establish the economic conditions with which the company would have had to contend if it had not been granted incompatible aid, Spain must take all the necessary steps to recover it from the beneficiary,
HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION: