They point out that, when it approved the Ekimen scheme (in December 1996), the Commission not only agreed to the definitions of "strategic" projects and "creation of jobs" to be used for the purposes of implementing the scheme, but also refrained from formulating any reservations of a sectoral nature, with the exception of a general reference to the sectors for which specific guidelines exist, which is not the case of the household appliances sector.
The Ekimen scheme draws a distinction between "strategic projects" and "strategic sectors", fulfilment of each of which criteria entitles the company concerned to an extra 5 % for the purposes of Article 10 of the Decree approving the Ekimen scheme.
Any project that fulfils the purely quantitative criteria, which the Commission accepted when it approved the scheme, constitutes a "strategic" project. The Commission is not entitled to modify these criteria without at the same time infringing the principles of legitimate expectations and legal certainty.
The regional authorities also argue that it is right to regard the household appliances sector as "strategic" since it accounts for 6 % of GDP in the region. The Competitiveness Programme for the Basque Country classifies the "large household appliances" cluster among the clusters whose development is given priority. This definition is based on the nature and extent of the competitive advantage and the contribution which the companies concerned make to value added and job creation in the Basque Country.
The regional authorities stress that, for the purposes of implementing the scheme, job creation is to be checked on the basis of objective data and not, as the Commission suggested when it extended the proceedings, in terms of the sectoral impact of Demesa's investment. This is confirmed, according to the regional authorities, by the guidelines on national regional aid, which state that "job creation" must be checked solely on the basis of the net number of jobs created in a particular establishment.