The specific nature of the measure is also strengthened by its purpose, as set out in Provincial Law 24/1996 establishing it. After listing the general objectives of the tax system, the preamble to that instrument enumerates another set of objectives that have more to do with industrial policy, among which it specifically mentions the aim of "stimulating the creation of new business initiatives", an objective pursued in the instrument by measures aimed at the specific category of newly created businesses (see point (g) of the preamble), which are granted a reduction in the tax base during the first four years of operation in which they make a profit. This stated objective, which confirms that the measure constitutes start-up aid for newly created businesses, does not enable it to be considered compatible with the nature or general scheme of the tax system in question. Neither did the regional authorities indicate or demonstrate in their response to the decision to initiate proceedings that the selective nature of the measure is justified by the "nature or general scheme" of the tax system concerned (see the judgment of the Court of Justice of 2 July 1974 in Case 173/73 Italy v Commission(54)).
The measure in question clearly constitutes operating aid. Since any profits will be generated in the future and are essentially uncertain, it is not possible to calculate precisely the aid intensity involved in the reduction in the tax base.
In its letter to Member States SG(89) D/5521 of 29 April 1989 the Commission stated that it "considers that a Member State has failed to fulfil its obligation to notify it where the process of putting aid into effect has been initiated. By 'putting into effect' it means not the action of granting aid to the recipient but rather the prior action of instituting or implementing the aid at a legislative level according to the constitutional rules of the Member State concerned. Aid is therefore deemed to have been put into effect as soon as the legislative machinery enabling it to be granted without further formality has been set up"(55). This is undoubtedly the case with this measure, which has been carried out unlawfully in breach of the provisions of Article 93(3) of the Treaty.