The bank is expected to be profitable once again in 2002, with a return on own funds of about 20 % and a return on the buyer's investment (ROI) of about 11 %. This would be the result of an appreciable recovery in the operating ratio, brought about by the redundancy programme and the synergies achieved in cooperation with the buyer's own group, and a return to a normal pattern with regard to the cost of risk.
The Commission concludes that the first test laid down in the Guidelines, namely that the firm must be restored to viability within a reasonable time, is satisfied.
5.3.2 The quid pro quo
In order to ensure that the aid does not have the effect of restoring to the market a firm which is excessively strong and in a position revert to an unreasonably aggressive policy, the firm receiving the aid must finance a significant part of the costs of restructuring out of its own resources. Under the principle laid down in the Guidelines, the recipient firm must not merely sell off subsidiaries and lines of business which are a burden on its accounts, but must also dispose of quality assets and subsidiaries, thus securing the resources necessary to finance restructuring, minimising the demands made on the public purse, keeping the amount of new aid to a minimum, and forcing the firm to make a significant contribution to its own restructuring.
Since 1992, SMC's balance-sheet total has been falling continuously, from FRF 24597 million in 1992 to FRF 23149 million in 1997, a drop of 16 %. This decline is the result primarily of a reduction in loans and advances to customers, reflecting the fall in funds employed (a drop of 18,9 % between 1994 and 1997), and of a 40 % reduction in leasing business as a result of the gradual decline in the volume of business of SMC's subsidiary PBS.
But these reductions are in part due simply to poor management.
The further action taken by SMC, and the business plan proposed by the private buyer, make provision for additional offsetting measures of three kinds.
The immediate and definitive abandonment of five lines of business
the closure of Soficim, one of the last French institutions specialised in real-estate loans direct to its own clientele (which is separate from the clientele of the network),
the sale of GP Banque, which was to have been the vehicle of SMC's development in the international sphere,
an end to the property-leasing business centred on the subsidiary PBS, which is to be sold,