The aid must be in proportion to the objectives pursued, and limited to the strict minimum necessary to enable restructuring to be undertaken, so that the effort of recovery is as far as possible borne by the firm itself.
The restructuring plan must be implemented in full, and any other obligations laid down by the Commission decision must be discharged.
Arrangements must be made for monitoring compliance with the preceding condition.
The information supplied by the French authorities at the time of the injections of capital into SMC in respect of 1993, 1994 and 1995 did not enable the Commission to make a proper assessment of the viability of the bank.
The new State measures to be taken in respect of 1997 are thus partly the result of the fact that the attempts at comprehensive restructuring undertaken since 1993 have failed.
The Commission accordingly takes the view that in these proceedings all the measures in support of SMC that constitute State aid should be considered for their compatibility with the Treaty together, in the light of the most recent restructuring plan, which was drawn up by the buyer.
5.3.1. The restructuring and viability measures
The restructuring plan submitted is based primarily on a continuation of the rationalisation already undertaken in the last few years. In the period 1994 to 1996 non-strategic holdings were sold off for FRF 221 million. Steps were also taken to reduce operating costs; these included staff reductions of about 1000 (772 between 1990 and 1994, and 210 between 1994 and 1997), and out-sourcing of financial and administrative skills within the retail banking business. SMC's commercial position declined by 20 % between 1995 and 1997. In the area it covers, its share of total funds employed fell by 20 %, from 2,55 % in December 1995 to 2,02 % in the second half of 1997.
Banque Chaix proposes to make SMC into a profitable regional bank able to finance its own development; this will require further efforts in a number of areas:
the remaining non-core businesses will have to be abandoned, and wound up or sold off,
there will have to be a significant and lasting reduction in operating costs,
organisation and working methods will have to be modernised and simplified.
The plan put forward by Banque Chaix covers the period 1997 to 2002; the main points are as follows.