In SMC's case, it appears at first sight that the sale might involve aid both to the buyer and to SMC, because the company is being sold by private treaty and because the sale was preceded by an increase in capital; but a more thorough examination of the procedure followed shows that it did provide the necessary transparency and impartiality.
The French Minister in charge, Mr Strauss-Kahn, issued a press release announcing the sale on 21 April 1998, and on 22 April a notice appeared in the Journal officiel de la République française stating that SMC would be sold by private treaty without any special conditions attached; the bank acting as consultant to the Treasury, Lazard Frères et Compagnie, then contacted 16 banks, both French and foreign, namely ABN AMRO; Argentaria, Spain; Banco de Santander, Spain; Banque Chaix; Banque Nationale de Paris; BBV, Spain; BCH, Spain; Caisse d'Épargne Provence-Alpes-Corse; Carron & Cie (Korkmaz Yigit Holding, Turkey); Cie Financière Edmond de Rothschild; Crédit Agricole; Crédit Mutuel; Groupe Banques Populaires; La Caixa, Spain; San Paolo, Italy; and SG. Four of these asked to inspect the documentation: Banque Chaix, Banque Nationale de Paris, Caisse d'Épargne Provence-Alpes-Corse, and SG. Only Banque Chaix made a firm offer to buy SMC, on 3 June 1998.
Of the banks contacted all those that manifested an interest in acquiring SMC were informed that before the handover, and after allowance for the consolidated net profit or loss for 1997, SMC would be recapitalised so as to comply with the European prudential and solvency ratios. The banks permitted to inspect the documentation were given a draft contract for the sale of SMC, which showed the figure for the recapitalisation and asked the prospective buyer to state what guarantee it required against any injury arising out of a liability whose origin had not been revealed or a tax liability which was identified but uncertain. The independent auditor had evaluated the guarantee for the tax risk at FRF 123 million, and this figure was shown to those who inspected the documentation.
Banque Chaix, the only prospective buyer to make a firm offer, asked for a guarantee against unrevealed liabilities and inaccurate statements amounting to FRF 300 million. On 12 June 1998 Banque Chaix signed the contract to take over SMC, subject to the condition that the Commission approve the aid given to SMC by the State.